Hand attack is one thing, but having a pickup which responds well to that attack is another.
I bought an old Dimarzio Super 2 and 3 recently from some bald swedish guy with a beard and a 540P-II (guess who :P) and put it in my 540P-II. The Super 2 has loads of attack in neck position, and the dynamics sound very Gilbert-ish to my ears. I actually think it he used it like, 20 years ago.
There are probably other pickups out there which are even better for what you want, but give it a shot if you can get it for cheap
