I had a chance to re-listen to all the tracks... so I'll give a little feedback. Keep in mind I'm just a schmuck that likes guitars and music - not an educated musician in any way... lol...
Craig - Fantastic job! Great sound and killer playing too... that descending lick at 1:32 was an absolute MONSTER! Great work overall. btw - What model is that guitar?
mt - Very tasty as usual. Nice subtle touch and volume knob usage really fit the track.. as well as the tasty lead work. Absolutely love that guitar and the way it sounds.
logic - I thought yours was fantastic. Sounded great with that sustainer type device you used. Very well done... and the vocal part fit the track nicely too.
Pirataz - I thought yours was very solid and flowed nicely. Good sounding guitar too. Sort of what I had in mind for the last half of my entry, but I fell well short of making it sound good. Great entry!
Razzle - Loved your sound on this! Best sounding guitar throughout the track. Very aggressive for a slow and mellow track, but it worked very well!
Laobi - Loved the intro guitar sound at 0:30... very rich tone! Thought you blasted into the solo like a brick though a window, but the contrast was awesome when you came out of the faster runs of the "solo end" and dropped the tempo at 1:52. Nicely done!
Advice to myself - In hindsight I should have stuck with the clean tones and just forced myself to come up with something better, instead of just finishing it in an improvised rush... guess I just got frustrated. I like doing these challenges because they drag me out of my comfort zone, but when I listened to the other entries after finishing mine I realized that you guys are all light years ahead of me. Gets a little discouraging at times... not sure if I should just keep trying or maybe take a few months off and try to learn how to play a guitar... lol.