I think if they had an outside producer they might make songs a little more musical.
Yeah I think so, it'd just have to be the right guy because Portnoy is a self confessed OCD control freak. I think they did better when they stayed closer to the style of SFAM and SDOIT. They got heavy but not near as heavy as they get now. I like the metal riffs a lot but, I just don't think the whole band is as cohesive on those songs. It's kind of hard to describe.
For example, on Train Of Thought I thought the guitar, bass and drums were killer and brutal but the band wasn't using all of everyones skill as well as it was used on SFAM and earlier records. And I think the same is true on Systematic Chaos, on some songs like, "In The Presence Of Enemies 1 and 2" they sound cohesive and like a band, but on songs like the, "Dark Eternal Night" it sounds like Petrucci and Portnoy (sometimes Myung) and some other guys trying to play along. That didn't happen as much on SFAM and before or on SDOIT. The right producer could help that a lot.
I get the feeling, lately, that they are trying to hide some of James' lost ability and how he doesn't fit the really heavy styles by mixing it with Mikes voice. I think in one way it's honorable to be loyal like that, James supposedly ruptured his vocal chords from having food poisoning a while ago. That's why he's not hitting those old super high notes all the time now. But you know, as the band brings in more really heavy styles and so on it doesn't always fit so maybe it's time to look elsewhere in my opinion. Or they could curtail their excess into chugga metal and help their cohesiveness.